References Case Studies Testimonials Evaluation Reports Training Reports

Evaluation Reports

This page contains evaluation and customer reports kindly provided by interested parties. Please note that these are individual assessments, that software products are subject to change during passing time and that each report refers to a particular application.

  • Project Thesis: QF-Test Evaluation of a GUI testtool (German PDF only), July 2017 – Sebastian Kühlewind, Carl von Ossietzky Universität Oldenburg, Germany.
  • Master's Thesis: Enhancing the Effectiveness of Software Test Automation, December 2015 - David Wayne Jansing, Department of Computer and Information Sciences, State University of New York Polytechnic Institute, Utica, New York, USA.
  • Bachelor's Thesis: Design and Implementation of test automation of interface tests between emergency response management systems and an emergency call system, August 2014 - Moritz Hegel, Hochschule Pforzheim, Germany.
  • Through positive long term experience with QF-Test PPI has been successfully established keyword and data-driven test automation for an RCP application framework at Talanx, a global B2B Insurance Group (German PDF only), May 2014 - Jörg Paelke, PPI AG Informationstechnologie, Hamburg, for Talanx Systeme AG, Hanover, Germany.
  • Data-and keyword-driven test case representation (German PDF only), January 2013 - Dirk O. Schweier, G. Muth Partners GmbH, Wiesbaden, Germany.
  • Bachelor's Thesis: Conception and implementation of a graphic Editor for different notations in the software development process (German PDF only), January 2011 - Peter Kolbe, TU Berlin, Germany.
  • Capture-Replay Regression Testing in Eclipse RCP (Blog posting), October 2009 - Christoph Schmidt, ubigrate GmbH, Dresden, Germany.
  • Diploma Thesis: Evaluation of tools for the automation of GUI-Tests (Extract concerning QF-Test), June 2008, Rainer Smekal, FH Joanneum Kapfenberg, Austria.
  • Diploma Thesis: Introduction of Java GUI based automated tests (Extract concerning QF-Test), March 2007 - Eyere Takem, Hochschule Fulda, Germany.

Test automation tools comparison with QF-Test

QF-Test compared to:Report

SikuliX and Jubula

Bachelor's Thesis: Test automation with QF-Test - QF-Test chosen for GIS program, Comparison with SikuliX and Jubula (German PDF only), September 2017 - Oliver Thomas, Technische Hochschule Mittelhessen, Giessen, Germany.

Selenium

Case Study: QF-Test replaces Selenium at the HPV November 2017 - Attila Enez, Hamburger Pensionsverwaltung, Germany.

Marathon,
Pounder and
Ranorex

Project Thesis: Evaluation of Swing-compatible Capture-and-Replay-Tools March 2016 - Daniel Kraus, Hochschule Karlsruhe – Technik und Wirtschaft, Germany.

Ranorex, GUI Dancer,
Sikuli and Maveryx

Advanced seminar: Draft of a test automation of TimeNet-GUI, December 2012 - Katharina Schröder, Technische Universität Ilmenau, Germany.

Automated GUI Recorder, GUIdancer, Unified Functional Testing, Squish and SWT Bot

Master's Thesis: Examination of automatable testing scenarios for User Interfaces of business software systems, August 2011 - Christian Froh, Hochschule Wismar, Germany.

Squish and GUIdancer

Evaluation Squish vs. GUIdancer vs. QF-Test:  From the user's point of view test cases, also in complex scenarios, could just be generated by QF-Test, Squish dropped out relatively fast. June 2010 - Sebastian Behrens, Micros Retail (former Torex), Berlin.

SWTBot

Diploma thesis: Conception and realization of a protocol model editor, chapter 3: Testsuite for a Graphic User Interface - QF-Test in comparison with SWTBot, January 2010 - Christoph Schmidt, TU Dresden, Germany.

Selenium and Windmill

Web-Test-Automation: Selenium vs. Windmill vs. QF-Test, July 2009 - Mark Michaelis, CoreMedia, Germany.

Squish

Why we chose QF-Test over Squish, July 2009 - Logan White Stack, R.J. Lee Group, Monroeville, USA.

Automated GUI 
Recorder, FIT, 
The Grinder, 
Silk Performer, 
Silktest, GUI Dancer, Loadrunner, Quicktest Pro, 
QA-Load and Squish

Project thesis: Test automation for software with a SWT-Rich-Client (RCP), Comparison of different GUI test tools (Open source and commercial), October 2008 - Patrice Förster, Staatliche Studienakademie Thüringen, Berufsakademie Gera, ALEA GmbH, Germany.

Marathon

Diploma Thesis: Test automation of net management systems, March 2008 (Extract concerning QF-Test) - Michael Werner, Hochschule Esslingen, Germany.

SilkTest, Squish and Marathon

Evaluation of GUI-test tools for Java Swing:  QFS QF-Test, Borland SilkTest, Froglogic Squish and Marathon, November 2007 - O. Krapp, M.Besemer, SBE network solutions GmbH, Heilbronn, Germany.

JUnit, djUnit and Jacareto

Project Thesis: JUnit in Comparison with JUnit, Jacareto and QF-Test (German PDF only), July 2007 - M. Graf, P. Hornig, K. Keller, Hochschule Mannheim, Germany.

WindowTester
and Automated
GUI Recorder (AGR)

Testing of Eclipse RCP-Applications, April 2007 - Steffen Schäfer, OIO.

Winrunner

Evaluation of QF-Test/qftestJUI at CoreMedia, January 2006 - Mark Michaelis, CoreMedia, Germany.

JFCUnit

Project Thesis: Test tools for Java/Swing User Interfaces, QF-Test/qftestJUI in comparison with JFCUnit (German PDF only), February 2005 - Florian Krämer, Hochschule Esslingen - Hochschule für Technik, Germany.

(Original German titles on this page are translated into English.)